Top 10 Super Bowls
David Lewis, Vice President of Operations
With Super Bowl 43 just days away now people begin to reminisce over Super Bowls past. What was the greatest performance in Super Bowl history? What was the greatest team to win it all? What was the greatest game ever played in the Super Bowl? Today I will tackle that final question and make a list on the Top 10 Super Bowls ever played.
10. Super Bowl III: New York Jets over the Baltimore Colts 16-7. This game isn’t up here because it was one of the closest games in Super Bowl history. Super Bowl 3 made the list because of its historical impact on the NFL. This was and will forever remained the greatest upset in Super Bowl history. Imagine the CFL Champions beating the Super Bowl Champions. Essentially that is what happened in this game with the inferior conference of the AFL besting the NFL. If the Jets did not win this game the owners of the AFL were going to pull out of the Super Bowl until they were able to compete with the NFL. The NFL and Super Bowl would be very different today if not for the Jet’s victory.
9. Super Bowl XXXIX: New England Patriots over Philadelphia Eagles 24-21. This is the only Super Bowl in league history where the game was tied at the beginning of the 4th quarter. Think about that statement. In 41 other Super Bowls the game was not tied heading into the final 15 minutes. The Eagles were close to pulling the upset over the defending champions where it seemed the Eagles outplayed the Patriots in the first half. However, in the fourth quarter the Patriots pulled away late and despite a late Eagles touchdown the underdogs could not comeback.
8. Super Bowl XXV: New York Giants over Buffalo Bills 20-19: The first of four straight Super Bowl losses for the Buffalo Bills which was made possible with a Scott Norwood miss of a 48 yard FG with 8 seconds left. The Giants were 6 point underdogs and few thought they could slow down the vaunted Bill’s offense. The Giants ran the ball down the Bills throat; leading to RB Otis Anderson being named MVP and the Giants controlling the ball for nearly 40 minutes. Despite only having the ball for only 1/3 of the game the Bills still had a chance to win the game. Norwood’s FG loss remains etched in the memories of Bills’ fans.
7. Super Bowl XLII: New York Giants over New England Patriots 17-14. For the most part this game was boring. If the Patriots held on to win 14-10 this game would be considered to be one of the worst by my standards. This was hyped up as an offensive shootout, yet the score was 7-3 entering the fourth quarter. Big plays by Kevin Boss and David Tyree led the Giants into the red zone. Eli then found Tyree who was completely covered by Asante Samuel in the endzone and a wide open Burress for the game winner. The monumental upset and comeback has this game on this list. However, if it wasn’t for the fourth quarter this game would not be on the list.
6. Super Bowl XXXVI: New England Patriots over St. Louis Rams 20-17. The Patriots had a chance to run away with this one. The game was 17-3 when Tebucky Jones ran a fumble back for 95 yards and a touchdown. The play was reversed on a holding penalty and the Rams scored a couple plays later. Instead of a 24-3 score the Rams were only down 17-10. The Rams answered again with less than two minutes left tying the game 17-17. Most people thought the Patriots should play for overtime and not risk giving the Rams the ball back in regulation. The Patriots had other ideas. Tom Brady led the Patriots down the field in 1:41. Adam Vinatieri then hit a 48 yard game winning FG. This is the only Super Bowl to have a team score as time expired.
5. Super Bowl XXIII: San Francisco 49ers over Cincinnati Bengals 20-16. The Bengals were only minutes away from a world championship title. The Bengals were up 16-13 with less than 3 minutes remaining. Joe Montana marched the 49ers down the field. Jerry Rice who had 215 yards already was expected to be the target in the red zone. Instead Montana found John Taylor for the game winning score and crushing the hopes of the Bengal team. The Bengals outplayed the 49ers for most of the game, but they allowed 2 TDs in the fourth quarter that cost the team the Super Bowl.
4. Super Bowl XIII: Pittsburgh Steelers over Dallas Cowboys 35-31. These two teams met three years prior in the Super Bowl where the Steelers won 21-17. It was deja vu as the Steelers won by four once again. The Cowboys had a chance to win the game, but a dropped touchdown pass by Jackie Smith allowed the Steelers to hold onto the lead.
3. Super Bowl XXXII: Denver Broncos over Green Bay Packers 31-24. This Super Bowl will be remembered for John Elway’s first Super Bowl win. Elway lost 3 out of 4 Super Bowls early in his career. Now he faced off against the defending champions who were 11 point favorites. The Packers thought the Broncos didn’t even belong in the game. The Packers came out to an early 7-0 lead. It seemed like Elway was going to be 0-4. However, the 37 year old would not be denied and the lasting image of this game is Elway diving and being hit midair. The hit made him spin and he landed for a first down. The Broncos scored with only minutes remaining to break the tie and take a 7 point. Elway’s determination and Terrell Davis’ 3 TDs allowed the Broncos to pull the upset.
2. Super Bowl XXXIV: St. Louis Rams over Tennessee Titans 23-16. The Rams were 4-12 in the 1998 season. Trent Green their starting QB was injured in the preseason. Kurt Warner, a man who was working in a grocery store the year before was now the starting QB. Warner exploded for 41 TDs that season and won the NFL MVP award. The Rams took a 16-0 lead on the Titans. The game seemed like a blowout. Then the Titans stormed back and were able to tie the game 16-16 with over 2 minutes remaining. On the Rams first play from scrimmage Warner hooked with Isaac Bruce for an 80 yard touchdown pass. It seemed the Rams scored too quick though. The Titans were able to march down into the red zone with :06 remaining. McNair hit WR Dyson on a slant; however he was tackled one yard short. Warner became the last regular season MVP to win the Super Bowl.
1. Super Bowl XXXVIII: New England Patriots over Carolina Panthers 32-29. If you can say one thing about the Patriots it is they play in great Super Bowls. They played in 4 of the 10 games on this list. The Patriots were trying to win their second Super Bowl in 3 years. The Panthers were 1-15 two years prior and were now in the Super Bowl. This game was all defense at first. The Patriots scored late in the second quarter, making it the latest the first score occurred in Super Bowl history. The Panthers answered and tied the game 7-7. With less than 2 minutes left the Patriots marched down the field and scored another TD to go up 14-7. With 15 seconds left the Patriots attempted a squib kick. The Panthers then ran a draw play where Foster ran for nearly 20 yards. The Panthers ended the half with a FG and the score was 14-10. At first this game was all defense then all of sudden there were four consecutive scoring drives to end the half. The third half was all defense once again. Both teams were shut out in the quarter. Patriots RB Smith scored a TD in the 4th putting the Patriots up 21-10. The Panthers responded with a Foster TD. The Panthers went for two and did not convert. The score was now 21-16. The Patriots were driving once again until Brady threw an INT in the end zone. Delhomme then connected with Mushin Muhammad for an 85 bomb. The Panthers were up 22-21 after a missed 2 point conversion. Muhammad’s 85 yard recepetion is the longest in Super Bowl history. The Patriots responded next drive with a TD from Brady to TE/OLB Mike Vrabel. The Patriots converted the extra two points on a direct snap to Kevin Faulk. The Panthers responded with a TD of their own and the game was tied 29-29 with only 1:04 remaining. John Kasay botched the kickoff and hit the ball out of bounds. The Patriots now had 1:04 on their own 40 with 3 time outs remaining, the best clutch QB in the game, and the best clutch FG kicker in the game. Needless to say Brady drove the Patriots down the field and Vinatieri hit a 41 yard FG with :04 seconds remaining to win the game. Both teams combined to score 37 points in the fourth quarter in what will be the greatest fourth quarter and I believe the greatest game in Super Bowl history.